Matthias Hester

Matthias Hester (1793-1890)

Class of 2026 – Founder

Matthias Hester was born in Green County, PA on Oct. 17, 1793, the son of John and Elizabeth (Mason) Hester.  The family moved to Columbiana County, OH in 1807, where Matthias became an apprentice tailor.  He then ran his own tailor shop in Salem, OH for about 10 years.  In 1836 he came to the village of Mount Union and opened a grocery store on the SE corner of the square.  In 1838 he relocated a couple of miles north and platted, along with John Miller, the village of Freedom.  Here he built a home and opened a mercantile shop which he ran until 1848. He built the Hester Block in 1838, which was the oldest brick home in the original town of Alliance. Hester was a big supporter of railroads and donated real estate then valued at over $6,000 in support of railroad development.  He was a Baptist when he founded Freedom, and he built the first church in Freedom, the Regular Baptist Church on Vine Street.  He served as a member of the first city council after Alliance was incorporated in 1854 and also as a member of the first public school board in Alliance.

In 1819 Matthias Hester married Susan Gaskill of Salem, and they were parents to ten children: David G; John N.; Sarah; Eliza; George W.; Charles M.; Thomas; Rebecca; Harrison; and another that died in childhood.  Matthias Hester died Feb. 11, 1890 and is buried in Alliance City Cemetery.

 

[Sources: 1881 Perrin, pp. 728-729; Arney article;   Hester House, 1869, Hester Block 1838]

 

Elisha Teeters

Elisha Teeters (1814-1899)

Class of 2026 – Founder

Elisha Teeters was one was one of the most important landowners and early developers in the growth of Alliance during the late nineteenth century.

At one time, Teeters owned nearly all of the land on which the early section of Alliance was built as he laid out a large portion of the town.

One of the most frequently cited accounts of early city development states that Elisha Teeters directed his son, Jesse Teeters, to plow a roadway through his farm property as land was being prepared for subdivision. According to early local histories, this roadway became the original alignment for what is now Main Street in Alliance, explaining why it is a dead end on the east.

Elisha Teeters was born on January 11, 1814, a few miles northeast of Alliance, to John and Mary Cook Teeters. He was the eldest son in a family of 10 children, his father having served as a colonel under General Harrison during the War of 1812.

On July 16, 1835, he married Eliza Webb (1818-1866). One month later, they removed to Lexington Township where he cleared an opening and built a home. Through hard work, he soon was the owner and operator of a flouring farm, being considered one of the most prosperous farmers in Stark County.

In the business of land development, Teeters was also involved in partnerships with other local leaders, including Levi L. Lamborn. These partnerships were responsible for laying out and selling large residential additions that supported the city’s rapid growth during the railroad era and helped establish much of the early urban grid.

During the early history of Alliance, Elisha Teeters was also engaged in the dry goods business and did considerable banking, being in partnership with his son Richard W. Teeters in that endeavor.

He was treasurer of the Lake Erie, Alliance & Wheeling Railroad Company. He was also president of the Nixon Agricultural works, an enterprise in which he lost surety money aggregating $250,000.

About 1875, he was elected Stark County commissioner, being reelected to several terms. For many years he was also a trustee of the Fairmount Children’s Home.

He was the father of 10 children, including Jesse W. Teeters (1836-19030) and Richard W. Teeters (1841-1899), who remained in Alliance, along with, Rachel (James) Amerman (1845-1931), and Laura (William) Fogg (1857-1942). Residing in Ohio were Mary “Sue” (John) Shimp (1838-1900) and Elisha Prentiss Teeters (1854-1923). Meanwhile, locating to Kansas was Isaac Teeters (1846-1900) and Charles Teeters (1852-1934). Rosa Jane (Chauncey) Edson (1850-1938) resided in St. Louis. A daughter, Eleanor P. Teeters, died in 1854 at the age of 10.

After the death of Eliza Teeters in 1866, he remarried on July 14, 1871, his second wife being Sarah R. Hester (1824-1907), the daughter of Mathias Hester, another founder inducted into the Alliance Historical Society Hall of Fame in the 2026 inaugural class.

Elisha Teeters died June 17, 1899, leaving behind a large number of grandchildren and a large estate. He is buried in the Alliance City Cemetery.

Matthew & Mary Earley

Matthew Earley (1829 – 1917)

& Mary Earley (1840 – 1900)

Class of 2026 – Founders

Matthew Earley was born in Poland, Ohio on Oct. 29, 1829 and came to the Alliance area in 1859.  He operated a tannery at Vine Street and Walnut Avenue, owned a machine shop in Bolton, Ohio, and was at one time a city councilman for Alliance. 

Mary Edwards was born on Apr. 16, 1840 in the Fairmount area of Washington Township, just south of Mount Union.  Matthew and Mary married in 1865.  In 1867 they built their beautiful Victorian Italianate home on North Park Avenue in what was then the village of Freedom.  The house is now owned and operated by the Alliance Historical Society

Mary Edwards Earley enjoyed taking care of her home and family and doing church work.  She was also a member of the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, Daughters of Rebekah, and Daughters of America.  Mrs. Earley gave financial and volunteer support to the schools, the public library, and the City Relief Committee. 

Matthew and Mary Earley never had any children of their own, but they did adopt Mabel Hartzell in 1885. 

Ellis Johnson

Ellis N. Johnson (1789-1889)

Class of 2026 – Founder

 

Ellis N. Johnson, of Mount Union, was one of the first settlers in what is now Alliance and celebrated his 100th birthday on April 1, 1889 – about five months prior to his death on September 15, 1889.

Born in Washington County, Pennsylvania, on April 1, 1789, he was born a month before the United States government officially began operation under the Constitution. At the time of his centennial, he was believed to be the only living Ohioan born before the nation had a president.

Upon his centennial, an article appeared in The Alliance Review, giving a sketch of his life that relayed the following facts and anecdotes:

Johnson came to Ohio in 1802 as a young man seeking opportunity on the frontier. After returning briefly to Pennsylvania to marry Dorcas Moffit in 1816, he settled permanently near present-day Mount Union in 1823. The following year he moved his family into a log cabin he built on the site where his later brick home stood. According to the article, this was the first family residence within what later became the city limits of Alliance.

Over the course of more than sixty years, Johnson served the community as a surveyor, Justice of the Peace, and notary public. He reportedly married more couples than any other man in the county. In 1841, he helped lay out the first section of Freedom, one of settlements that later became Alliance, and he maintained a strong interest in the city’s growth throughout his life.

Johnson and his family were active supporters of the Underground Railroad in Washington Township, assisting freedom seekers escaping slavery on their journey to Canada. A lifelong advocate of temperance, he organized Mount Union’s first temperance society and became known as a powerful and persuasive public speaker. Many stories circulated about the conversions he made. One of his converts was his own brother, Job Johnson, who was in the hotel business at the time.

Dorcas Johnson (1798-1835)  died  at the age of 36 while on a trip back to her childhood home in Washington County, Pennsylvania. In 1836, Ellis Johnson married Mary Ann Graves (1811-1889), also from Washington County, Pennsylvania.

Throughout his life, Johnson made remarkable connections to prominent figures in American history. He was acquainted with Robert Fulton, inventor of the steamboat, and knew members of the Blaine and Gillespie families, including Neal Gillespie, grandfather of statesman James G. Blaine, who was serving a second term as Secretary of State. Mary A. Graves, had taught the young Blaine his alphabet and first reader lessons.

Among the many famous Americans Johnson met were Henry Clay, General Winfield Scott, and President William Henry Harrison, from whom Johnson preserved a personal letter dated February 9, 1839. He also met the Marquis de Lafayette during Lafayette’s 1824 return visit to America. Johnson delighted in recounting how he once engaged the towering Scott in a friendly wrestling match and managed to throw him to the ground.

Politically, Johnson began as a Whig. After a period as a Free Soiler, he eventually joined the Republican Party. He proudly claimed to have voted in every presidential election from Thomas Jefferson onward.

His centennial celebration brought congratulatory letters and telegrams from notable public figures, including President Chester A. Arthur’s administration, former President Grover Cleveland, Ohio Governor Joseph Foraker, Pennsylvania Governor James Beaver, and James G. Blaine, who praised both Johnson’s longevity and the character he had maintained throughout his life.

According to his obituary that ran in the Stark County Democrat, published in Canton, Ellis and his brother Simon came to Ohio from Pennsylvania in 1823, built cabins, and then returned to Pennsylvania to bring their families west in 1824.

It noted that Johnson was a speaker of some note and had served Washington Township for a time as a surgeon and was several time elected mayor of Mount Union.

The obituary stated that he never had a sick day is his 100 years.

Ellis Johnson had six children with his first wife, including James M., Betty (William) Davidson, Caleb, Ellis N. Jr., John M., and Rebecca (John) Miller.

Five children were born to Johnson through his second wife, including David G., Mary (Jerry) Lee, Dorcas (Williamson) Teeters, Charles, and Ella (Lee) Grimes.

It should be noted, Ellis N. Johnson Jr. (1825-1902) was a founder Southwestern Normal School (later California University of Pennsylvania) and served as its first principal in 1852 was later a member of the state legislature from 1870 to 1874. He also was appointed to positions in the U.S. Treasury and the U.S. War Department.

It should also be noted that Mary Ann Graves Johnson, his second wife, followed Ellis into eternity just two days after his passing. They are buried in Mount Union Cemetery.

Nathaniel Gaskill

Nathaniel Gaskill (1774-1841)

Class of 2026 – Founder

Nathaniel “Nathan” Gaskill laid out the village of Lexington in 1807 along with Amos Holloway.  Located at the intersection of the diagonal roads from Salem to Cleveland and from Deerfield to Canton, the settlement and the township took their name from the battle of Lexington in the Revolutionary War.  The settlement was on the banks of the Mahoning River, which was a grand waterway at the time, as it was declared navigable by act of legislation. 

The son of Daniel and Huldah (Mott) Gaskill, he was born in Burlington County, New Jersey, in 1774, A Quaker farmer, Nathan Gaskill married Hannah Owens (1774-1845) in Burlington County, New Jersey, in 1797. They were among five families that originally settled in Lexington. They had 10 children, including Martha, Joseph (1798-1866), Elizabeth Hamlin (1801-1876), Daniel IV (1802-1854), Israel, Abigail Wood (1807-1869), Abraham (1808-1895), Levi, Mary, and Wesley.

After its formation in 1807, Nathan Gaskill became the first justice of the peace of Stark County in 1812. He also served a second term in 1817.

Gaskill died in 1841 and is buried in Canal Fulton.

Amos Holloway

Amos Holloway (1759-1842)

Class of 2026 – Founder

Amos Holloway was credited with platting the village of Lexington, along with Nathan Gaskill. The village, which does not exist today, was the first settlement in Lexington Township – both named after the Battle of the Revolutionary War.

Holloway, was born on September 7, 1759, in Burlington County, New Jersey. He married Hepzibah Stanton (1770-1824) in October 1785 in Lynchburg, Virginia. The Quaker couple had several children and were among five families that located to present Lexington Township in 1805-06 to live in a state that did not allow slavery.

Holloway, a farmer, was credited with building the first house in Lexington Township with a shingled roof. That structure later became the village’s first store.

Amos Holloway died in December 1842 and is buried in Lexington Quaker Cemetery.

Listed among his children are Phebe Holloway Frey (1787-unknown), Stephen Holloway (1789-1877), Rhoda Holloway Burden (1789-unknown), Job Holloway (1793-1824), Aaron Holloway (1795-1873), Huldah Holloway Hatfield (1798-1863), Jason Holloway (1801-1884), Anna Holloway Rockhill (1803-1870), Elizabeth Holloway Gaskill (1805-1875), Margaret Holloway (1808-1855), Zebulon Holloway (1810-1810), Lydia Holloway Buckman (1812-1906), Sarah Holloway Pellett (1814-1857), and Amos Holloway Jr. (1816-unknown).

Orville Hartshorn

Orville Nelson Hartshorn (1823-1901)

Class of 2026 – Founder

Orville Nelson Hartshorn was the founder and first president of Mount Union College.

Born on August 20, 1823, in Nelson, Ohio, Hartshorn was visiting a gravely ill sister in the village of Mount Union in 1846 when local residents learned that he had been a teacher in Meadville, Pennsylvania, and requested he start a school for their children. On October 4, 1846, Hartshorn founded Mount Union Seminary with six students on the second floor of a carding mill. In January 1858, it was chartered as a college.

On November 1, 1849, Hartshorn married Amanda Melvina Brush (1828-1909). The couple had five children – Lucetta Abigail “Setti” Hartshorn Jacob (1850-1932), Dora Hartshorn Lehman (1854-1905), Homer Hartshorn (1865-1926), Emma Hartshorn Beck (1865-1926) and Walter B. Hartshorn (1867-1921).

An ardent fighter for the cause of temperance, Hartshorn was licensed to preach by the Methodist Episcopal Church in 1852. He was a professor of moral and intellectual philosophy and international law at Mount Union College in addition to serving as president of the institution until 1887.

After hearing of the assassination of President William McKinley on September 6, 1901, Hartshorn had a series of attacks and died on September 17, 1901. He is buried in Mount Union Cemetery.