Mayors of Alliance, Ohio

• Harvey Laughlin, 1854-1856
• Harvey Chapman, 1856-1857
• Harvey Laughlin, 1857-1859
• Linus Ely, 1859-1860
• Simon Johnson, 1860-1861
• Moses Buck, 1861-1862
• Joseph Barnaby, 1862-1865
• A. L. Jones, 1865-1866
• H. Buck, 1866-1868
• Isaac Ewan, 1868-1869
• I. I. Parker, 1869-1870
• H. Laughlin, 1870-1872
• J. F. Oliver, 1872-1873
• Simon Johnson, 1873-1874
• David Fording, 1874-1876
• Joseph Barnaby, 1876-1877
• David Fording (mayor or mayor pro tem one month), 1877
• John M. Day (or) John L. Day, 1877-1880
• Simon Johnson, 1880-1886
• O. M. Coxen, 1886-1888
• Charles Chapman, 1889-1890
• John Stillwell, 1891-1894
• M. B. Excell, 1895-1896
• W. H. Dressler, 1897-1900
• O. U. Walker, 1901-1903
• John McConnell, 1904-1909
• E. P. Speidel, 1910-1913
• W. P. Barnum, 1914-1915
• C. S. Westover, 1916-1921
• Norman Clark, 1922-1923
• Ira Stevens, 1924-1927
• Carl Hari, 1928-1931
• C. S. Westover, 1932-1933
• Guy Allott, 1934-1937
• Floyd H. Senn, 1938-1943
• Sam Kirkland, 1944-1946
• Wade W. Shidler, 1946-1948
• Robert Althouse, 1948-1949
• Harley Ewing, 1949-1958
• David Mainwaring, 1958-resigned Jan. 21, 1963
• Dr. William M. Morgan, Jan. 21, 1963-resigned Feb. 28, 1963
• Gus E. Graf, Feb. 29, 1963-died June 5, 1963
• Dr. William M. Morgan, June 5, 1963-
• Dale Walborn, 1963-1971
• James Puckett, 1972-1984
• Francis Carr, 1984-1992
• Julius Tonges, 1992-1996
• Judy Carr, 1996-1999
• Toni Middleton, 2000-2011
• Alan Andreani, 2012-2023
• Andrew Grove, 2023-